Eating Through History: Diet, Catastrophe, Institution, and the Human–Earth Relationship

Introduction: Food as Destiny

Food has always been more than sustenance. It has been the axis of survival, culture, spirituality, and political power. The long arc from Australopithecine tuber-digging to industrial feedlots is a story of both necessity and imagination, shaped by climate shocks, catastrophic events, evolving institutions, and shifting human relationships with the natural world.

Every major dietary transition—the move from wild plants to meat, from foraging to farming, from ritual sacrifice to industrial slaughter—emerged from ecological pressures and cultural responses. Droughts, floods, volcanic winters, and glacial oscillations forced humans to improvise. Technologies such as fire, fermentation, and storage enabled new forms of subsistence. Institutions of religion and state sacralized or exploited these transitions, sometimes reinforcing ecological balance, sometimes accelerating extraction.

This paper traces the deep historical trajectory of human diet with attention to the ecological overlays, institutional frameworks, myths, and rituals that framed each shift. It argues that while humans have always survived by dietary flexibility, our relationship with plants, animals, and ecosystems was mediated through stories and institutions that either supported or undermined health. Today, as climate disruption and mass animal suffering converge, the adaptability that once preserved humanity must be consciously reactivated to restore balance.

1. Plant Foundations: A World of Roots and Fruits

Australopithecines and Early Hominins

The earliest hominins, Australopithecines (4–2 million years ago), subsisted largely on plant foods: fruits, nuts, leaves, and underground tubers (C₃ and C₄ plants). Dental microwear shows heavy grinding surfaces, while isotopic analysis reveals diets rooted in C₃ and C₄ plants of African woodlands and savannas. This resembles the dietary strategies of chimpanzees and baboons, where plants dominate caloric intake and animal foods are opportunistic.¹

Fallback Foods and Survival

Even in this early phase, climate variability influenced diet. As African environments oscillated between wetter and drier periods, plant availability fluctuated. During droughts, Australopithecines relied on “fallback foods”—hard seeds, fibrous roots, and underground storage organs that required strong jaws and high effort. These foods were not preferred but sustained survival in ecological stress.²

Cultural Echoes of Plants

Though prehistory leaves no myths, later traditions often remember plants as primordial foods: the fig tree of Eden, the lotus of South Asia, the maize of Mesoamerica. Such myths may preserve deep cultural memory of a time when plants defined the bond between humans and the earth.

2. Climate Shocks and the Meat Turn

Scavenging and Opportunism

Around 2.5 million years ago, Homo habilis emerged with the first stone tools (Oldowan industry). Cut marks on fossil bones suggest scavenging: splitting open carcasses for marrow or brains after carnivores had finished.³ This shift corresponded with cooler, drier climates that reduced fruit-bearing trees and forced reliance on calorie-dense animal remains.

Hunting and Homo erectus

By 1.9–1.5 million years ago, Homo erectus had developed Acheulean handaxes and may have practiced persistence hunting: exhausting prey through long-distance running.⁴ This innovation coincided with brain expansion. The “expensive tissue hypothesis” argues that energy-rich animal foods allowed smaller guts and larger brains, reshaping human physiology.⁵

Catastrophic Overlays

The Pleistocene epoch (2.5 mya–12,000 years ago) brought repeated glacial cycles. During glacial maxima, plant biomass shrank; humans turned to megafauna like mammoths and aurochs.⁶ Volcanic eruptions intensified these pressures. The Toba supereruption (~74,000 years ago) created a volcanic winter, reducing photosynthesis and plant growth across continents. Surviving populations likely relied heavily on marrow, shellfish, and famine plants.⁷

These events show that the meat turn was not inevitable cultural preference but adaptive response to repeated ecological shocks.

Institutions of Early Hunting

Even in later hunter-gatherers, animal death was mediated by ritual. Inuit hunters offered water to seal spirits; San hunters in southern Africa apologized to antelopes with ritual dances. Such practices framed hunting as reciprocity rather than domination, embedding restraint within myth and ceremony.⁸

3. Fire and the First Food Revolution

Archaeological Evidence

The control of fire marked the first great dietary revolution. Wonderwerk Cave in South Africa preserves burned bones and ash layers from ~1 million years ago.⁹ At Gesher Benot Ya’aqov (Israel), hearths dated to 780,000 years ago contain charred seeds, wood, and fish bones.¹⁰

Nutritional Transformation

Cooking softened tough roots, detoxified tubers, and made proteins more digestible. This increased caloric extraction from both plants and meat. Cooking also reduced chewing time, shortened digestion, and may have supported smaller jaws and teeth. Wrangham argues that cooking was essential to sustaining larger brains in Homo erectus and beyond.¹¹

Social and Institutional Fire

Fire extended waking hours and created social centers. Hearths became proto-institutions: sites of story, cooperation, and ritual. Food moved from individual to collective resource, binding early societies in shared meals.

Mythic Echoes of Fire

Later myths recall fire as divine gift: Prometheus stealing fire for humanity, Maui bringing fire to Polynesians, Agni as the Vedic fire god. These stories encode cultural recognition that fire was no mere technology but a civilizational threshold that transformed diets, societies, and human relation to nature.

4. Marine Abundance and Flood Memory

Shell Middens and Coastal Cultures

By 90,000–50,000 years ago, coastal populations systematically harvested marine foods. Shell middens in South Africa reveal abalone, mussels, and limpets.¹² The Jomon of Japan (14,000–300 BCE) left vast shell mounds testifying to reliance on fish, mollusks, and sea mammals.¹³ Fish provided omega-3 fatty acids critical for neural function, and shellfish harvesting offered predictable returns with low risk compared to large-game hunting.

Sea-Level Rise and Catastrophe

At the end of the Ice Age (~12,000–8,000 years ago), melting glaciers raised sea levels by ~120 meters, flooding fertile coastal plains. Populations adapted by intensifying inland farming or turning to rivers and lakes for sustenance. Flood myths—Noah in the Bible, Utnapishtim in Gilgamesh, Manu in the Śatapatha Brāhmaṇa—may encode memory of these catastrophic shifts.¹⁴

Institutional Memory of Water

Water became central in ritual: baptism in Christianity, ablutions in Islam, offerings in Hinduism. These practices sacralized the medium of survival, echoing deep prehistory where survival often depended on aquatic foods and riverside settlements.

5. Agriculture and the First Civilizations

The Neolithic Revolution

Roughly 12,000 years ago, as the Ice Age waned, humans in multiple regions began cultivating plants and domesticating animals. The Levantine Natufians harvested wild cereals before domestication. At Göbekli Tepe in Anatolia, monumental stone enclosures dating to 9600 BCE suggest that ritual preceded the village and that feasting on grain and wild game accompanied ceremonial life. Agriculture was not a single invention but a gradual convergence of techniques—domestication, irrigation, storage—that reshaped human diets and societies.¹⁵

Terra Preta and Sustainable Practices

In the Amazon, Indigenous communities produced terra preta—fertile anthropogenic soils enriched with charcoal, bone, and compost. These black earths sustained diverse polycultures, contrasting sharply with the monocultures of Eurasian cereal farming.¹⁶

Institutionalization of Food

Agriculture enabled surplus. Surplus enabled storage. Storage enabled hierarchy. Priesthoods, states, and armies emerged around granaries. Food shifted from communal to institutional resource, and diets reflected this change. While elites feasted, commoners subsisted on monotonous staples. The first famines of history were byproducts of institutional mismanagement as much as natural catastrophe.

6. Sacrifice, Domestication, and the Politics of Meat

Domestication of Animals

Goats, sheep, cattle, and pigs were domesticated between 10,000 and 8,000 years ago in Southwest Asia. Animals provided not only meat but milk, wool, traction, and manure. Yet their domestication also intensified human–animal relations, raising new ethical and ritual concerns.

Sacrificial Economies

In Vedic India, the horse sacrifice (aśvamedha) dramatized kingship and cosmic order. In Mesoamerica, human and animal sacrifices nourished the gods and guaranteed agricultural fertility. In the Mediterranean, Greek festivals such as the Panathenaia revolved around animal offerings whose meat was redistributed in civic feasts. These institutions legitimized animal killing by embedding it in cosmic necessity.¹⁷

Meat and Social Stratification

Meat was often a marker of class. In Mesopotamia, temple sacrifices redistributed animal flesh selectively. In Rome, amphitheater spectacles slaughtered thousands of beasts, glorifying conquest and power.¹⁸ For commoners, plant foods—bread, pulses, and beer—remained the staples. Meat’s symbolic value outweighed its nutritional role, reinforcing inequality.

Ritual as Restraint and Justification

Rituals surrounding hunting and sacrifice could restrain excess by requiring offerings and acknowledgment of animal spirits. Yet they could also justify large-scale killing by sacralizing it. This dual function—restraint and license—was a hallmark of institutional food systems.

7. Medieval Food Systems: Faith, Famine, and Feast

Christian Fasting and Abstinence

With Christianity’s spread, food became entwined with morality. The Church imposed fasts and prohibitions on meat, especially during Lent and on Fridays. Abstinence was framed as discipline and spiritual purification. These practices reduced meat consumption across medieval Europe and reinforced community through shared rhythms of feast and fast.

Islamic Dietary Laws

In Islam, dietary laws distinguished between halal and haram, reinforcing purity and community boundaries. Pork was forbidden, while ritual slaughter sacralized permissible meats. Fasting during Ramadan restructured eating into daily cycles of abstinence and feasting, embedding diet in sacred time.

Buddhism and Vegetarian Currents

In parts of Asia, Buddhist monastic traditions promoted vegetarianism rooted in compassion and non-harm. Although not universal, these traditions preserved ancient ethical restraints, keeping alive the possibility of diet as moral practice.

Peasant and Elite Diets

For medieval peasants, diets centered on cereals—rye, oats, barley—supplemented with legumes and seasonal vegetables. Meat was scarce, often reserved for feasts or stolen hunts. Aristocrats, by contrast, consumed meat more frequently, along with imported spices and wines. This imbalance echoed earlier stratifications: plants for the many, meat for the few.

Famines and Climate

The Great Famine of 1315–17 devastated Europe after torrential rains destroyed grain harvests. Populations turned to bark, grass, and horse flesh. Climate variability—whether through volcanic winters or medieval cold spells—remained decisive in shaping diets. These crises revealed the fragility of cereal dependence and the limits of institutional relief.¹⁹

8. Feasts, Festivals, and the Ceremonial Life of Food

Food as Display of Power

Banquets were central to medieval and early modern political life. Kings displayed wealth through lavish feasts featuring roasted game, sugared confections, and imported wines. These spectacles normalized elite abundance while contrasting sharply with peasant scarcity.

Ceremonies of Offering and Return

In many Indigenous traditions, food remained embedded in reciprocal cosmologies. Among the Haudenosaunee, the Thanksgiving Address honored animals, plants, and waters before meals. In the Andes, pachamama offerings returned portions of harvest to the earth.²⁰

Festivals as Social Regulation

Carnival, Ramadan feasts, and harvest festivals reinforced cycles of restraint and release. Institutions channeled communal energies through ritualized abundance, preventing disorder. Yet they also perpetuated hierarchies, as elites controlled surplus and spectacle.

9. The Industrial Food Break

Refrigeration, Mechanization, and Global Trade

The Industrial Revolution unleashed unprecedented changes in diet. Mechanized slaughterhouses, refrigeration, and canning made it possible to move meat across oceans and continents. Grain-fed livestock systems expanded, especially in North America. Colonization integrated cattle, sheep, and pigs into landscapes where they were once absent, transforming ecosystems in the Americas, Australasia, and Africa.

Refrigerated ships carried Argentine beef and New Zealand lamb to Europe; American pork and salt cod fed urban laborers. Food was no longer tied to local ecology but embedded in global trade networks.

Extractive Colonial Diets

Colonial expansion restructured global diets: Caribbean sugar, Indian spices, African coffee, and South American beef flowed to European markets. Local subsistence systems were displaced. Livestock became an instrument of colonization: cattle ranching seized Indigenous lands; sheep grazing eroded soils. Food systems turned extractive on planetary scale.

Industrial Meat as Daily Staple

Where earlier meat had been a feast food for elites, industrial abundance made it a daily staple. Marketing and advertising reframed meat as symbol of progress, masculinity, and health. Institutions shifted from restraining consumption to encouraging it. Yet this abundance carried hidden costs: deforestation, methane emissions, water depletion, and loss of biodiversity.²¹

10. Institutions and Healthy Behavior

When Institutions Supported Health

In many historical contexts, institutions restrained unhealthy behavior. Religious fasting reduced meat intake; hunting taboos limited overexploitation; Indigenous ceremonies reinforced reciprocity. Monastic gardens preserved plant knowledge; village feasts strengthened community bonds. These practices aligned human diets with ecological rhythms.

When Institutions Negated Health

Modern institutions often undermined health. Governments subsidized meat and dairy; corporations promoted sugar, salt, and fat-heavy diets. Colonial administrations disrupted sustainable plant-based traditions, replacing them with export monocultures. Marketing normalized overconsumption while obscuring ecological costs.

The Dual Face of Institutions

Institutions have always cut both ways. They are scaffolds for restraint and discipline but also engines of exploitation. The medieval Church enforced fasts yet hoarded wealth; empires ritualized sacrifice yet glorified conquest. Modern agribusiness globalized abundance but eroded ecosystems. Institutions mediated diet not neutrally but in ways shaped by power.

11. Climate Crisis and Modern Collapse

Livestock as Driver of Instability

Today, animal agriculture accounts for roughly 14.5% of global greenhouse gas emissions, a major driver of climate disruption. Vast tracts of rainforest are cleared for cattle ranching and soy feed. Industrial fishing collapses ocean ecosystems, creating dead zones and depleting fish stocks.²²

Pandemic and Zoonotic Risks

Dense factory farms provide breeding grounds for zoonotic diseases. Influenza, coronaviruses, and antimicrobial resistance all find fertile conditions in industrial animal systems. Dietary institutions that once promoted resilience now amplify global health risks.²³

A New Catastrophe

As in the Pleistocene, catastrophe again shapes diet. Droughts, floods, and fires linked to climate change threaten harvests. Unlike earlier humans, however, today’s populations cannot scatter or adapt locally; they are tied to global markets and industrial infrastructures. Adaptation now requires intentional transformation, not improvisation.

12. Ethics, Rituals, and Animals

Ancient Reciprocity

Ancient hunting rituals acknowledged animal spirits. Inuit hunters poured water into a seal’s mouth to honor its sacrifice; Plains tribes sang to the buffalo; Siberian reindeer herders offered smoke to animal souls. These ceremonies recognized nonhuman agency and framed killing as exchange.²⁴

Rituals of Justification

Other traditions sacralized animal death to justify large-scale killing. Aztec sacrifices, Roman spectacles, and Vedic rituals all normalized slaughter by embedding it in cosmic order.²⁵

Modern Denial

Industrial slaughter eliminates ritual. Billions of animals live and die without acknowledgment of agency. Their deaths are hidden, mechanized, and stripped of ceremony. Where once ritual provided restraint or justification, modernity offers only denial.

New Ethical Movements

Animal rights campaigns, vegan activism, and ecological spirituality represent emergent institutions of restraint. They revive ancient intuitions—that to kill is morally weighty—while grounding them in modern science and ethics.

13. Hidden Evidence and Plant Futures

Archaeological Bias

For decades, archaeology emphasized meat because bones fossilize while tubers and fruits decay. This distorted narratives of early diets. New techniques—starch grain analysis, phytoliths, dental calculus—reveal that ancient humans consumed diverse plants: sorghum, barley, yams, legumes. Plant foods were central all along.²⁶

Terra Preta and Agroecological Models

Archaeological rediscovery of terra preta in the Amazon demonstrates that sustainable, plant-based agroecologies once flourished. Similar traditions in Africa, Oceania, and Asia reveal complex systems of polyculture and soil management. These findings challenge the narrative that human agriculture was always extractive.²⁷

Plants and the Future

Modern nutritional science confirms what prehistory suggests: humans can thrive on diverse plant diets. Supplementation ensures adequacy for nutrients such as B12. In embracing plants, humanity is not innovating but returning to deep traditions of ecological reciprocity.

14. Re-Adaptation: Becoming Herbivores Again

Nutritional Sufficiency of Plant Diets

Modern nutritional science demonstrates that well-planned plant-based diets meet human needs at all stages of life. Protein can be obtained from legumes, grains, and nuts; omega-3 fatty acids from flax, chia, and algae; iron and zinc from beans and seeds. The only nutrient requiring supplementation is vitamin B12, a microbe-derived compound once obtained from soil and water but now safely provided synthetically.²⁸

This confirms what prehistory already revealed: plant foods sustained the majority of daily calories, with meat as occasional supplement. The Industrial period inverted this balance, but adaptation is possible again.

Case Studies of Plant-Based Longevity

The Okinawans of Japan, long celebrated for longevity, ate diets rich in sweet potatoes, soy, and vegetables, with minimal animal foods. Seventh-Day Adventists in California live longer than the U.S. average on plant-based regimens. Mediterranean peasants, until the mid-20th century, thrived largely on cereals, legumes, and vegetables, reserving meat for rare occasions. These examples demonstrate that plant-centered diets are both historically rooted and scientifically validated.

Re-Adaptive Potential

Just as early humans adjusted diets to glacial droughts or volcanic winters, modern societies must adapt consciously to climate disruption. The difference is agency: where ancestors improvised under duress, today’s populations can choose deliberately, guided by science and ethics. Re-adaptation requires new institutions: public health guidelines, subsidies for legumes and vegetables, policies discouraging deforestation-linked beef, and education on plant-based nutrition.

15. Conclusion: Diet, Institutions, and the Near World

Diet has always been the hinge of human survival. From tubers to megafauna, from shellfish to grains, from sacrificial lambs to industrial feedlots, the human story is a record of improvisation and institutional mediation. Catastrophe repeatedly forced change: droughts and ice pushed toward meat, floods and fires toward plants, storage toward hierarchy, and industry toward excess.

Institutions sometimes sacralized restraint—fasts, taboos, thanksgiving rituals—and sometimes amplified extraction—spectacles, feasts, subsidies. The myths and ceremonies that once reminded humans of animal agency or ecological reciprocity have given way, in many modern contexts, to denial and commodification. Yet the same adaptability that allowed survival through Ice Ages and volcanic winters can now guide deliberate return to plant-centered diets.

The climate crisis is the latest catastrophe, but unlike earlier ones, its outcome hinges not on improvisation but choice. If humans re-align appetite with ecology, institutions with restraint, and ceremonies with gratitude, diet can once again become the ground of health for people, animals, and planet alike.

Endnotes

1. Sandi Copeland et al., “Strontium Isotope Evidence for Landscape Use by Early Hominins,” Nature 474 (2011): 76–78.

2. Craig B. Stanford, The Hunting Apes: Meat Eating and the Origins of Human Behavior (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1999), 44–46.

3. Henry T. Bunn and Ellen K. Kroll, “Systematic Butchery by Plio/Pleistocene Hominids at Olduvai Gorge, Tanzania,” Current Anthropology 27, no. 5 (1986): 431–52.

4. Christopher B. Stringer, The Origin of Our Species (London: Penguin, 2011), 105–10.

5. Leslie C. Aiello and Peter Wheeler, “The Expensive-Tissue Hypothesis: The Brain and the Digestive System in Human and Primate Evolution,” Current Anthropology 36, no. 2 (1995): 199–221.

6. Paul S. Martin, “Prehistoric Overkill: The Global Model,” in Quaternary Extinctions: A Prehistoric Revolution, ed. Paul S. Martin and Richard G. Klein (Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1984), 354–403.

7. Stanley H. Ambrose, “Late Pleistocene Human Population Bottlenecks, Volcanic Winter, and Differentiation of Modern Humans,” Journal of Human Evolution 34, no. 6 (1998): 623–51.

8. Piers Vitebsky, The Reindeer People: Living with Animals and Spirits in Siberia (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2005), 77–108.

9. Michael Chazan et al., “Evidence for the Control of Fire at Wonderwerk Cave, South Africa,” PNAS 109, no. 20 (2012): E1215–E1220.

10. Naama Goren-Inbar et al., “Evidence of Hominin Control of Fire at Gesher Benot Ya’aqov, Israel,” Science 304, no. 5671 (2004): 725–27.

11. Richard Wrangham, Catching Fire: How Cooking Made Us Human (New York: Basic Books, 2009), 74–87.

12. Curtis W. Marean et al., “Early Human Use of Marine Resources and Pigment in South Africa,” Nature 449 (2007): 905–8.

13. Junko Habu, Ancient Jomon of Japan (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004), 92–97.

14. J. M. Adovasio and David Pedler, The Peopling of North America: Renewed Debates and Controversies (Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 2016), 201–4.

15. Klaus Schmidt, Göbekli Tepe: A Stone Age Sanctuary in South-Eastern Anatolia (Berlin: ex oriente, 2006).

16. Bruno Glaser et al., “The Terra Preta Phenomenon: A Model for Sustainable Agriculture in the Humid Tropics,” Naturwissenschaften 88 (2001): 37–41.

17. Walter Burkert, Homo Necans: The Anthropology of Ancient Greek Sacrificial Ritual and Myth (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1983).

18. Michael Dietler and Brian Hayden, eds., Feasts: Archaeological and Ethnographic Perspectives on Food, Politics, and Power (Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 2001).

19. William Chester Jordan, The Great Famine: Northern Europe in the Early Fourteenth Century (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1996).

20. John Mohawk and Oren Lyons, eds., Exiled in the Land of the Free: Democracy, Indian Nations, and the U.S. Constitution (Santa Fe: Clear Light, 1992), 173–80.

21. Harriet Ritvo, The Animal Estate: The English and Other Creatures in the Victorian Age (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1987).

22. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), Tackling Climate Change Through Livestock (Rome: FAO, 2013), 12–14.

23. Kate E. Jones et al., “Global Trends in Emerging Infectious Diseases,” Nature 451 (2008): 990–93.

24. Jonathan Safran Foer, Eating Animals (New York: Little, Brown, 2009), 95–121.

25. Donald G. Kyle, Spectacles of Death in Ancient Rome (London: Routledge, 1998).

26. Dolores R. Piperno et al., “Starch Grains on Human Teeth Reveal Early Broad Crop Use,” PNAS 101, no. 35 (2004): 12736–41.

27. Alfred W. Crosby, The Columbian Exchange: Biological and Cultural Consequences of 1492, 2nd ed. (Westport, CT: Praeger, 2003).

28. Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, “Position of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics: Vegetarian Diets,” Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics 116, no. 12 (2016): 1970–80.